Snape loved Harry's mother Lily, so that is why he figures himself as the father of Harry. The book, however, is a bit more subtle. Dumbledore just said that this patronus mirroring wasn't that weird. i think cause snape had a thing for lilly. Because in the movie, dh2, in the death scene where harry is talking to dumbledore in the train station, harry references the visions he had from snapes tears. While Dumbledore trusted him, Harry didnt, and consequently neither did the readers. This time, however, she wasn't here. How does fear control us, and why might it be hard to be Latest answer posted August 22, 2019 at 4:46:51 PM. They were born in the same month and year. Were drip-fed with information about his past bit by bit. When Lily got sorted into Gryffindor, and Snape into Slytherin, he got a bit envious and started disliking James. Harry Potter: 10 Memes That Prove Snape Was The Real Hero - ScreenRant While it doesn't excuse Snape's behavior at the time, James Potter's seemingly only redeeming moment from that period of his life was his decision to keep his friend from accidentally killing someone. Who has ever heard of Severus Potter anyway? Severus Snape is not Harrys father. 35 Things You Might Not Know About Harry Potter - Mental Floss RELATED: Harry Potters Most Powerful Potion Might Be The Reason He Ended Up With Ginny. Snape once made an appearance in an episode of the TV show. Please, I think you're on to something. In the books, Snape is one of the youngest teachers to be recruited at Hogwarts school. Despite Snape and Lily's bond, they still argue, especially when her sister, Petunia Harry's bitter Muggle aunt gets involved. Snape has carved out a place for himself among the most remembered and loved characters in the saga. What made the fans who didnt read the book think that way ?? J.K. Rowling stated that Lily Evans may have grown to love Snape romantically if he was not so drawn to the Dark Arts. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Fortunately, Rowling always seems eager to fill in the blanks for her readers. A new professor at the school, Lupin's presence escalates the anger felt by Snapetoward the past. Why Snape's Line About Harry Potter's Eyes Isn't A Plot Hole On a 2019 episode of the UK game show "There's Something About the Movies," actor Tim Roth said that he was offered the role of Snape the same year he was cast in Tim Burton's "Planet of the Apes.". It is 100% obvious that James is Harry's father because Sirius is his godfather because Sirius was James's best friend. The movie watchers are confused, just as I am, because when Harry is in the pensive with Snape's memories, Snape and DD are talking. Alan Rickman played Snape in the "Harry Potter" films. And, perhaps, one of the characters that best embodies the duality of human nature is Severus Snape the heartbroken man who built a shell to hide his true goodness. Plus, Snape was never the true master of the Elder Wand, due to the fact that Dumbledore, who was dying of a terrible curse, asked Snape to kill him when the time came. Can We dream it? In 2015, the series' author began answering a slew of fan questions on Twitter. I guess alot of those who read the book know nothing about movies and how thay make things appear to be something their not and oh yeah EVERY DETAIL is not included in a movie from a book and important details get left out. What J.K Rowling Doesn't Want You To Know About Harry Potter's ParentsSubscribe: http://bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Things DO YOU BELIEVE IN MAGIC | Potterheads: h. Well, both roads ultimately lead to Snape. All his actions lead us to believe that hes on the side of Voldemort and the Death Eaters. Okay, now I read the books. He covers breakouts on comics, film, television, video games, and anime. Severus Snape's biggest regret. It's also why Tonks' patronus had changed into a wolf form in the sixth book, because she loved Lupin. You mean you didn't notice the resemblance? Though Snape is handed the truth about Sirius on a silver platter, his hatred of the wizard clouds his judgment, as Sirius was once his schoolyard rival. Get what I mean Its just so unbelievable! Snape is not Harry Porter's father but to make it clear, James Potter is his father. Several factors combine to give him powerful charisma, from his eerie, snake-like appearance to his merciless attitude to his powerfully compelling ideas and force of will. It doesnt talk about the question at all! The Potions Professor at Hogwarts despite his history as a former member of Voldemort's Death Eaters, Snape is shown to have a personal distaste for Harry specifically.This is eventually revealed to be a by-product of Snape's lingering resentment for Harry's father, James -- who had . Next Ron and Hermione, sittin' in a tree. Snape's death is one of the most emotional moments in the series. Coincidence? Severus is also forced to wear mismatched clothes, suggesting he may have been neglected by his parents. No. Didn't you post this crap a week ago? Latest answer posted May 20, 2020 at 2:49:33 AM. Yes, I like you. In the books, the resemblance between James and Harry is pretty much stuffed down our throats, but it isn't possible to find two unrelated actors who'd be that similar. Tonk's patrous turned into a wolf but for awhile people thought she had been in love with her cousin Sirus but in reality it was Lupin. At the end of Harry's fourth year, after Voldemort officially returns, Snape returns to his former master at Dumbledore's orders. And that's whenSnape shows up and does the job himself. Published Aug 27, 2022. In the book, Nagini kills Snape by sinking her fangs into his neck after being released from her protective bubble. Upon their shared arrival at Hogwarts, Lily is furious at Snape for sabotaging her relationship with her sister, and matters only get worse from there. 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. He was a pure-blood wizard married to Lily Evans Potter, Harry's mother. However, this didn't relieve the rivalry between the two young men. Snape was not Harrys father. In a series of tweets, Rowling explained her reasoning. Latest answer posted December 07, 2017 at 11:40:19 PM. At the end of POA, when Snape discovers Sirius is missing, he immediately suspects Harry and flies into a rage to accuse him. This is eventually revealed to be a by-product of Snape's lingering resentment for Harry's father, James -- who had been a major rival to Snape in their youth. Throughout the Harry Potter series, the Dursleys treat Harry very cruelly in regards to his magic. Actor, In the film adaptations, Severus appears to be rather older than he is in the original books, being in his early thirties at the time of. Is Snape Harry's Father? On top of that, Snape finds Harry to be arrogant and mediocre, as well as a boy who breaks rules to gain fame and glory. Harrys father is, was, and will always be James Potter. This relationship will be key to discovering more about Snape as an adult in the Harry Potter saga. Snape's responsibilities include monitoring the welfare and discipline of those in Slytherin House and just generally assuming charge of the students. Though Dumbledore tells Harry that Snape protects him as a debt to James, he doesn't divulge anything further, and the enmity between Harry and Snape continues. The only reason snape's pstronus is a deer is because he loved lily, and she died. Snape had a doe as his patroness. When we came out of the theatre my sister was wide eyed and shocked I felt proud that I read the books and she didnt because she looked confused so I told her in the I-read-the-book-and-you-didnt tone "Al right Alice what is it that got you confused from the movie I can answer ANYTHING.." she turned to me and said: "One question: Is Snape Harry's REAL father" I just wanted to slap her when I heard that question and its not just her my friends asked me THE SAME THING. And two, a lot of things in the movies suggest snaps is always protecting him and helping him. How does fear drive their actions? One notable factor of the books was when Harry was speaking about Snape with Dumbledore, the latter would always ask Harry to address him as "Professor Snape". For all these reasons and more, we can say that Severus Snape is one of the most complete and fascinating characters in the Harry Potter universe. If Snape was jealous of James, it would make sense such jealousy could result in disabling James, who essentially persecuted Snape during Hogwart's schooling. He names his eldest son after James and Sirius. They met as children and became great friends. Professor Slughorn, his Potions Master, was very fond of both Snape and Lily, so they were both likely a part of his elite student group, the Slug Club. When Harry explores them, he learns everything he needs to know. But if they don't quit asking, tell them to tell you the reason why they think Snape is Harry's father. are you guys really watched the movie? Though Snape was hard on Harry and his friends throughout the series, he was deeply in love with Lily Potter, Harry's mom. So, Be nice don't laugh at people beacause they don't know what happened in the book, next time you could be the clueless individual. People tell me how it's more detailed but I get where and why people think snape is Harry's father. Warner Bros. Pictures. James is the one who ended up with Lily and married her thus conceiving Harry. This shows that, sometimes, our senses deceive us. Harry Potter creator J.K. Rowling poses for photographers in central London, on June 23, 2011. There's a whole essay in why Harry gave his son Snape's name, but the decision goes to the heart of who Harry was, post-war. Or at leat in the book they did. There is no reason to question that James may not be Harrys dad. Seeing as he was a double agent, this also fits. I did not read books 5-7 so I'm not sure what they say. Is there such a thing as pure goodness? She was mad and asked him why is he going out with the other "bad" Slytherin guys and thought that they influence him or had already influenced him to call people mudbloods. Severus Snape's infamous line about Harry Potter's eyes in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 isn't actually a Harry Potter plot hole. What a funny, but undeniable explanation. even the novel delivered that message, but there is no bloodline between harry and snape and btw it doesnt say that, snapes patronus is a deer (doe) for lily because he loved her (obviously) because lily's is also a deer (doe), his patronus has nothing to do with harry or a bloodline but all to do with lily (and love ). The group was caught and punished as a result. 111,505 views May 15, 2016 1.2K Dislike Share ColenMate 147 subscribers I remember when I did Harry Potter's marathon few years ago and in the last movie I. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Who are the main characters in "Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets?". 7 WEAKNESS: His Abusive Upbringing Makes Him Disdain Muggles. Is there something in the movie DH-part 2 made them think Snape is Harry's father ?? They don't replace the diagnosis, advice, or treatment of a professional. Lily deserved much better. Harry inherited the stag form from James. Despite his status as a Death Eater as well as implications that he had some form of status among them before Voldemort's attack on the Potters, Snape did not seem to be aware of Peter Pettigrew's role in the Death Eaters nor was he aware that Peter was actually the one who betrayed Lily to Voldemort as he seemed sure that Sirius Black was the culprit. The films give the impression that Snape grew up alongside Lily and her sister, Petunia. Was Snape Harry's real father? : r/harrypotter - reddit A few years back, one fan asked the author directly about her decision. 2023 TIME USA, LLC. You see your self in DH 2 James making a fool of Snape and James looks just like harry for a REASON!!! Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. The reason some people believe this is because in the movie when harry dies and meets Dumbledore, harry asks if its curious that Snape has the same Patronous as Lilly. Snape died for Harry out of love for Lily. Harry Potter went through a lot with his two best friends, Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger. i.m.o. Thank you fanfiction by saying this you are stating that some poor young defenseless teen or tween boy or girl thought of this absolutely brilliant theory that woulld drive us potter heads up the wall and make us want to Avacadarva our selfs ITS FANFICTION THERE BY MADE UP, because people get confuse with the patronus.. some people thought that the patrunus was from Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban.. and in that movie harry said that was his father who made the patronus but later we all knew that was harry.. so people doesn't remenber that.. so when snape sent the patronus for help harry to find the sword of griffyndor there is the confuse..I say this because I heard it in the theater and then when he said "always" people thought again that maybe lily and severus had some kind of a affair.. but in my case a second later I said this is impossible because harry is identical to james, and When Harry died and talked to Dumbledore, he himself said, Professor Snape's Patronus was a doe, exactly like my mother'sharry said that was interesting or something like that i don't remeber the exact word and then dumbledore told harry that wasn't at all .. that part confused people to because of the way that harry said that question. During Harry's sixth year, the Boy Who Lived finds himself completely consumed by a few mysteries. "Think about what you are saying. His father was neglectful and sometimes abusive, which may have contributed to Snape's disdain for Muggles. Rowling has shared a number of revelations since the Harry Potter books and films wrapped upincluding the fact that Dumbledore was gay. Unequivocally no. Snape takes out all his past frustration on Harry, whom he sees as a reflection of his father and, consequently, as an enemy and rival. So unbelievable! He appears to do something wrong and yet, in the end, it turns out that he was acting in Harrys best interests. You can't make him a devil: he died to save the wizarding world. ", Rita Skeeter is a journalist and author in the Wizarding World known for her sensationalized tell-alls, including "The Life and Lies of Albus Dumbledore.". I think the doe petronus shared by Snape and Lily can have another less sinister explanation than Snape is Harry's father. except techinally in a sense Snape is probably related to Harry on his dad's side and Snape's mom's side (James Sr. and Ellieen Prince both being pure-bloods). Is Severus Snape related to Harry Potter? - Quora A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News. Also, he's compared to James all the time, saying that they're practically identical other than eye colour and scar. . The Life and Times of Savannah Snape, a harry potter fanfic | FanFiction Obviously from the books' standpoint James is Harry's father. Harry Potter fandom is one of the largest, most active and productive in the world. According to the official Wizarding World site, his last name is based on the Old Norse word "sneypa" meaning "to outrage, disgrace or dishonor." She was putting MORE thought into than most people who read the books. " No thank you Tom I will go up and see him myself" Snape said. I read the first book and I instantly knew that Snape was an enemy of Harry. And, in the same way, we understand that good old Dumbledore wasnt quite as good as we thought he was. So when Harry was talking to Dumbledore after he died, he said "Isn't it curious that Snape and my mother share the same patrons us?" So the first time I say DH pt. The petronus is a bloodline link but on the maternal side, Snape and Lily could be brother and sister, it explains all the growing up together memories and Snapes love for Lily and by extension Harry. Though Lily assures her friend that she can't stand James, an altercation with the young bully ends in nastiness when Snape calls Lily a "Mudblood," a horrible slur referring to Muggle-borns and it effectively ends their friendship forever. Snape did confront Harry about the missing ingredients for the potion. Also, it just dawned on you? If by real you mean through genes the answer to that is James Potter. They think that Snape is the real father because the whole time he spent odd amount of time watching Harry and making sure he didn't screw up and not just because Dumbledore "Was raising him like a pig for slaughter." Also most kids want to look like their parents. For a long time, we thought that, without a doubt, Dumbledore was the good guy and Snape was the bad guy. Harry Potter: Short Summaries of All the Movies. If Snape was Harry Potter's father, how would the story be - Quora A/N: I do not own any of the characters in this fanfiction except for the original character that I have named Savannah Snape. No matter how hard Dumbledore tries, Voldemort slaughters Lily and James, leaving only Harry alive and Snape bereft. Not this shit again! But Snape's attempts to uncover the truth resulted in Sirius teasing that the truth was at the Shack. It's obvious Snape is NOT Harrys father. As Harry begins his third year at Hogwarts, he receives an alarming piece of information. I mean, peaple brought it from films where actors have a certain hair color. Our suspicions are confirmed when we discover that Severus Snape is indeed one of them, and that he even murdered the person who had always trusted him: Albus Dumbledore. What seemed to be a childrens story has now become a dark and nuanced one. Because Snape killed Dumbledore, Voldemort believes the wand will obey Snape, so he must defeat his right-hand man. He savesthe boy's life on multiple occasions, which Dumbledore notes to Harry is partly because James had once saved Snape's life when he was a member of the Marauders. Although both families did live in the fictional English town of Cokeworth, they resided in two different neighborhoods. Snapes story moves us deeply; hes the repentant mortal who sacrifices his life for the son of the person he loved. Press J to jump to the feed. However, the roles of good and evil seem to blur over time. For example, why is Draco Malfoy acting weirder than normal? And that when he agrees to protect Harry he says no one can know. Not that the love had been mutual or that he was Harry's father. Why did Uncle Vernon lock Harry in his room inHarry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets? from a genetic standpoint, it seems unusual Harry has coal black hair color, like Snape, when his alleged parents each possess the gene for red hair as seen in the movie showings of Lily and James when they were children. Actually he did meet Lily again after he called her mudblood. Harry is Snape's father Just read a fic where Harry got thrown back in time and fell in love with Eileen Prince and fathered Snape. It used to belong to someone who went by the nickname of "the Half-Blood Prince," and this mysterious student scribbled quite a few notes in the pages that help Harry unlock the secrets of some truly powerful potions. Though Harry, Ron, and Hermione are convinced that Snape is working with Voldemort to try to steal the stone, it turns out that Professor Quirrell, the Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher, is the one actually searching for the magical item as he's possessed by the weak, bodiless spirit of the Dark Lord. Due to the age difference between Rickman and Snape, as he is portrayed in the book, make-up was used on Rickman to make him look younger. Snape is pedantic, arrogant, and lacks empathy. That's because Snape has always liked Lily since childhood. In the case of any doubt, it's best to consult a trusted specialist. For requests, comments, or to hear his pitch for a third Avatar series that incorporates robots, you can reach him atbs.zachary@gmail.com. Who is Harry Potter's real dad? One of the keys to the Harry Potter saga is the depth and complexity of its characters. Next time you read a book and then go see the movie try not going in with preconceived notions (con, I already know what happens doesn't look good on you when you're laughing at others because they don't) and really watch the movie like you've never heard the story before and stop sitting there dictating every line, that's no fun. Dumbledore has been preparing Harry to die at the hands of Voldemort all this time, while Snape has been looking out for him at the risk of his own life. Throughout most of the Harry Potter franchise, Severus Snape was the Potions professor with a knack for bullying students he didn't like. When Snape accidentally injures Petunia using magic, she calls Lily a "freak," while Lily reveals that she and Snape saw a letter that Petunia wrote, begging Hogwarts to accept her as a student. It's just a fact. Haven't they read Philisiphers Stone? Harrys plans almost always fail, and Snape comes out on top every time. If you like the idea of Snape secretly being Harrys dad, there are fanfics devoted to this trope that you can read, just know theyre not canon. Articles and opinions on happiness, fear and other aspects of human psychology. 2012 2023 . My thoughts were Snape loved Lily would do anything for her so sacrificing himself wouldn't be far fetched and I cant imagine disguising a dead body would be difficult. I wouldn't have been surprised. Severus Snape | Harry Potter Wiki | Fandom And maybe they thought that because of Snapes memories of Lily and how he really did Love her and still did until he died. When Harry has difficulty shutting off his emotions to practice occlumency, Snape doesn't help anything, and their tension hits a breaking point when Harry inadvertently invades Snape's mind and sees a memory of his father, James, cruelly bullying Snape for no reason. Snape stays by Voldemort's side throughout the Battle of Hogwarts, which turns out to be a fatal mistake. The only thing that made me think otherwise is the JAMES that they picked for the movie. Because the movies leave out more than half the details from the books. In The Deathly Hallows, the last book in the saga, we realize that there are no longer any people who we could classify as good or bad. Who is Harry Potter's real father? However, Snape isn't the only villainous character in the series that uses a Patronus. This way, Draco's soul would be spared. Well for one, some make fanfictions and theories about the story. Snape waves his wand producing his potronus and it's the same as Lillies. It's likely however that he learned the truth following Voldemort's rebirth as he showed much less hostility towards Sirius than before (while still a significant amount) and he was made aware that Peter was alive and on the side of the Death Eaters. Ultimately, Albus Severus as detailed in the Tony Award-winning play Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is sorted into Slytherin just like one of this two namesakes, eventually becoming close friends with Scorpius Malfoy (Draco's son) and setting off on a time-bending adventure befitting his father and both of the men for whom he was named. All rights reserved. Is Severus Snape really Harry's dad? - eNotes.com However, Snape was truly a part of the Order of the Phoenix and . Harry's Real Father Severus Snape was sitting on the bank of the murky river near Spinner's End like he used to with Lily Evans, his long time crush. Characters in the books that knew James clearly state that Harry is James' son because he looks like James. In the books it's repeatedly mentioned that Harry has the exact same hair as his father. Doesnt he look just like James, with Lilys eyes? Rickman was Rowling's first choice for the role. Can you explain the major problem in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, without telling the climax? But maybe when Voldemort kills Snape, and he gives the teardrop to Harry, maybe that confused her or something. The shared doe patronus meant that Snape had loved Lily. As far as a crazy 'open-ended' plot twist, that's where my mind took it. Warner Bros. Severus Snape is one of the most divisive characters in the entire "Harry Potter" series. Born to Muggle Tobias Snape and witch Ellen Prince, young Severus Snape has a difficult childhood due to a strained and often angry relationship between his parents, which Harry personally witnesses when he accidentally glimpses one of Snape's private childhood memories. It's probably a conspiracy theory or something like that. Harry asked about his mothers patroness also being a doe. After giving his life to defeat Voldemort, Harry is able to return to the realm of the living and face Voldemort one last time, and as the true master of the Elder Wand, he brings the Dark Lord down for good. She also cleared up doubt as to whether Professor Snape held malice against Harry or his father, James Potter. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. We all shed a few tears when we discovered that, after all this time, Snape still loved Harrys mother Lily and that, in fact, everything he had done was to ensure the young mans safety.